To Understand Nazuna

There are characters out there who are accused of being overly bland. They’re decried as dragging the quality of a series down below where it should be, and not contributing as much to their respective series as other characters. More recently, this accusation has been leveled at the new girl Nazuna in Hidamari Sketch Hoshimittsu.

While I believe it is possible for characters’ blandness to hurt a series (see a large number of harem shows), and I also understand the desire for characters that aren’t wishy-washy, I feel that in many cases, particularly with Nazuna, these criticisms do not do these characters justice.

By comparison with the other girls in Hidamari Sketch, Nazuna can definitely seem more “bland,” especially because of her passive personality, but I think that passive personality goes a very long way in making her a good character. While the entire rest of the girls in Hidamari Apartments are artists and creative types of all varieties, ranging from a computer graphics specialist to a published writer of short stories, Nazuna is not. Already meek and soft-spoken, this deals a subtle blow to her already wobbly confidence levels. Because she worries about not being “good enough” or “smart enough,” Nazuna is sometimes afraid to speak her mind. The other girls don’t really think any less of her, but in her mind there is a wide chasm separating her from the others. She worries that she might not truly “belong” with the others.

Personally, I think this quality of Nazuna’s makes her a fine character, though I can see why others dislike her. I’m somewhat hesitant to bring out the “moe” argument in all this, but I think it really applies here. Nazuna is a very strong example of a character with a lot of “moe” to her, in that those who like her enjoy the fact that she has such a complex, while those who think she makes the show worse probably think that such “blandness” is the last trait any character should have, especially in a comedy like Hidamari Sketch.

Now you might think that Nazuna is getting a free pass because she’s a girl and that she’s cute, but the idea of having trouble finding some place to belong is a common trait among people both male and female, and this extends to characters as well. To find one, we need go no further than my favorite series, Genshiken, and its main character, Sasahara Kanji.

Sasahara is a somewhat closeted anime fan who in the beginning hasn’t developed his taste in anime anywhere in particular. To some extent he is a reader surrogate, being a newbie to the wild world of PVC figures and doujinshi, but over time his experiences with Genshiken enable  him to mature as both a person and as an otaku. Overall, he is a well-written character.

Moe is not really a factor in real life and when dealing with real people, but it is an abstraction of reality. And so it’s a very real worry to have, to think that you’re just not good enough to hang with your friends and that they might just be humoring you. I once talked to a friend from high school who told me that while hanging out with our group of friends, they were always concerned about not being interesting or quirky enough. I don’t think any of us thought of that friend in that manner, but there it is.

6 thoughts on “To Understand Nazuna

  1. Wasn’t Yuno just like that the beginning ? (and she is still somewhat like that), but as time went by she has matured and started to be more open and decisive.

    In time with the help of the other 5 girls Nazuna could overcome her anxieties and worries and to be a person to be proud of.

    Like

  2. I find myself feeling many moe, “weak,” or self-conscious characters as my “reader surrogates” in a show. I just can’t help identifying with them. To me that’s an aspect of moe that isn’t often thought of: that we all have some moe inside us, hidden as it may be. So moe characters don’t have to be looked at just as objects (to be pitied, helped, desired), but can be subjects, too.

    Like

  3. Hm, now you’ve piqued my interest in this series. As someone who used to have a terrible image of himself, I can relate to that vexation. You just have to find your strengths and be proud of those or accept the fact that you suck as an achiever and just let others appreciate your friendship for what it means to them.

    Like

  4. I get pretty tired when people describe shy as “moe” because in real life it’s not cute at all. I guess Nazuna is pretty lucky to be attractive, but most of the time shy + ugly (on the outside) = no one likes you. It’s the harsh reality, and to a certain extent I can understand it. If no one knows how you are on the inside, they can only judge you from the outside… errrrr, perhaps I’m getting off topic! (/RL)

    Anyways, I think people should give Nazuna/Nazna a break. She just entered High School, so she has plenty of time to develop.

    Like

  5. Pingback: A Little Bit on Yuno and Nazuna « Drastic My Anime Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.