Who Cares About Gold? “Free!”

Free! and Free! Eternal Summer spoilers below.

Whenever Free! ends, it really knows how to communicate its core values, whether it’s the original series or Eternal Summer. Ostensibly about competitive swimming, these finales basically say that, unlike so many other sports anime and manga, that winning not only isn’t everything, but it isn’t even that important in the first place.

At the end of season 1, the character Rin joins his old friends for a relay at a high school competition, revitalizing the lifelong bond he’s had with them. They swim better than they ever have before and even win the race, but run into the issue that Rin is from a different school that’s also competing at the event. The team is disqualified, but what’s emphasized here is that getting first was not the point. Rather, what they have truly achieved is strengthening their relationships with each other.

In the final episode of season 2, the main cast reaches the nationals for relay, and during the race each character has a vision of the joy of swimming. The main character, Haruka, is the last member to race, and upon entering the water sees his teammates swimming alongside him. When he reaches the finish line, everyone cheers, and we’re greeted with images of the team smiling and hugging. By all narrative and film convention, it looks as if they had won the whole thing, but later we see that they only got 6th place. They weren’t celebrating their championsip, but their accomplishments as a group. Moreover, Haruka, who throughout Eternal Summer has felt pressure over the fact that becoming a professional swimmer means having to care about trophies and times, ultimately finds that, for him, winning is merely a way to swim more, a means to an end.

Free! is geared towards a female audience. Whether it’s the well-animated flexible and muscular swimmers’ bodies on the cast, gentle yet strong personalities, or their close and sometimes tumultuous bonds, this is an anime that provides visual fanservice in a way that not even series like The Prince of Tennis or Kuroko’s Basketball could offer. Those other series, still grounded in their shounen sports manga formulas, end up emphasizing winners and losers first and foremost, but Free! is all about the relationship known as friendship, reflecting a desire to get away from the stereotypically male desire of victory through competition.

This is not to say that manga for male audiences based in competition necessarily always emphasize winning (see the manga Touch!), nor that there is no such thing as a manga for a female audience that stresses the competitive environment (Chihayafuru). However, when looking more broadly, what I find is that series that try to draw in men and boys primarily will often use friendship and teamwork as a means to victory, while series that target women and girls will do the opposite and use competition as a means to friendship and teamwork.

Sometimes targeting a demographic isn’t wholly intentional, but this is how a fanbase is formed anyway, and other times it can be hard to tell which is which. It might even flip back and forth throughout a given series. Free! doesn’t have any of that ambiguity. It knows exactly what it wants, and in the end we have to wonder for ourselves if winning is that big of a deal.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Who Cares About Gold? “Free!”

  1. Just want to point out a subtle thing.

    You say “shounen sports manga formula” but I don’t know how that is meaningful or descriptive in that it addresses, in any way, to a male audience. The examples you raised, for example, are consumed mostly by female, so the question is in this post, are you using the term descriptively or prescriptively?

    What I’m getting at is I’m not sure if your point about male and female views on friendship versus winning are actually substantiated by your supporting examples. To be clear, I don’t even disagree, but it just sounds if you put things down this way, you are prescribing the conclusion without taking into account if that’s really the case in terms of what people like to read.

    To that end, isn’t Free not such a thing anyway? The editorial process is likely very different than making manga in the traditional shounen mag style.

    Like

  2. Women’s stories of competition including friendship and love,
    I give you “Yawara, a fashionable Judo girl”. It is not entirely
    out in the manga but the anime is completely available from
    subtitler’s who could have done a better job with the judo
    moves and manuvers but I got the licensed first 40 episodes
    from AnimEigo which came with a booklet on the terminology
    and other such esoteric matters.
    First Yawara is pushed into training from the age of 5 then
    in late HS is debuted and the HS judo team seeks her advice
    and she enjoys training them.
    She tries to abandon judo repeatedly even after encountering
    other powerful judoka and winning a gold medal
    but is brought back into the sport by the efforts of her friend in
    training a college team of misfits. When she was isolated by her grandfather from other judoka she was unhappy because she
    was not part of a group.

    I don’t want to say too much more about this but the anime series
    runs to 120 episodes and about 2 movies. I have recently started
    rewatching this series and it repays close watching. We have
    humor and pathos, love and…
    And typing anything more would be too much, but all praise
    to the Live/Frozen Evil subtitling teams.

    bliss

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s